Tuesday, December 21, 2010

A Working Definition of Business Logic, with Implications for CRUD Code

Update: the Second Post of this series is now available.

Update: the Third Post of this series is now available.

The Wikipedia entry on "Business Logic" has a wonderfully honest opening sentence stating that "Business logic, or domain logic, is a non-technical term... (emphasis mine)". If this is true, that the term is non-technical, or if you like, non-rigorous, then most of us spend the better part of our efforts working on something that does not even have a definition. Kind of scary.

Is it possible to come up with a decent working definition of business logic? It is certainly worth a try. This post is the first in a four part series. The second post is about a more rigorous definition of Business Logic.

This blog has two tables of contents, the Complete Table of Contents and the list of Database Skills.

The Method

In this essay we will pursue a method of finding operations that we can define as business logic with a minimum of controversey, and identify those that can likely be excluded with a minimum of controversey. This may leave a bit of gray area that can be taken up in a later post.

An Easy Exclusion: Presentation Requirements

If we define Presentation Requirements as all requirements about "how it looks" as opposed to "what it is", then we can rule these out. But if we want to be rigorous we have to be clear, Presentation Requirements has to mean things like branding, skinning, accessibility, any and all formatting, and anything else that is about the appearance and not about the actual values fetched from somewhere.

Tables as the Foundation Layer

Database veterans are likely to agree that your table schema constitutes the foundation layer of all business rules. The schema, being the tables, columns, and keys, determines what must be provided and what must be excluded. If these are not business logic, I guess I don't know what is.

What about CouchDB and MongoDB and others that do not require a predefined schema? These systems give up the advantages of a fixed schema for scalability and simplicity. I would argue here that the schema has not disappeared, it has simply moved into the code that writes documents to the database. Unless the programmer wants a nightmare of chaos and confusion, he will enforce some document structure in the code, and so I still think it safe to say that even for these databases there is a schema somewhere that governs what must be stored and what must be excluded.

So we have at least a foundation for a rigorous definition of business rules: the schema, be it enforced by the database itself or by the code, forms the bottom layer of the business logic.

Processes are Business Logic

The next easy addition to our definition of business logic would be processes, where a process can be defined loosely as anything involving multiple statements, can run without user interaction, may depend on parameters tables, and may take longer than a user is willing to wait, requiring background processing.

I am sure we can all agree this is business logic, but as long as we are trying to be rigorous, we might say it is business logic because:

  • It must be coded
  • The algorithm(s) must be inferred from the requirements
  • It is entirely independent of Presentation Requirements

Calculations are Business Logic

We also should be able to agree that calculated values like an order total, and the total after tax and freight, are business logic. These are things we must code for to take user-supplied values and complete some picture.

The reasons are the same as for processes, they must be coded, the formulas must often be inferred from requirements (or forced out of The Explainer at gunpoint), and the formulas are completely independent of Presentation Requirements.

The Score So Far

So far we have excluded "mere" Presentation Requirements, and included three entries I hope so far are non-controversial:

  • Schema
  • Processes
  • Calculations

These are three things that some programmer must design and code. The schema, either in a conventional relational database or in application code. Processes, which definitely must be coded, and calculations, which also have to be coded.

What Have We Left Out?

Plenty. At very least security and notifications. But let's put those off for another day and see how we might handle what we have so far.

For the Schema, I have already mentioned that you can either put it into a Relational database or manage it in application code when using a "NoSQL" database. More than that will have to wait for 2011, when I am hoping to run a series detailing different ways to implement schemas. I'm kind of excited to play around with CouchDB or MongoDB.

For processes, I have a separate post that examines the implications of the stored procedure route, the embedded SQL route, and the ORM route.

This leaves calculations. Let us now see how we might handle calculations.

Mixing CRUD and Processes

But before we get to CRUD, I should state that if your CRUD code involves processes, seek professional help immediately. Mixing processes into CRUD is an extremely common design error, and it can be devastating. It can be recognized when somebody says, "Yes, but when the salesman closes the sale we have to pick this up and move it over there, and then we have to...."

Alas, this post is running long already and so I cannot go into exactly how to solve these, but the solution will always be one of these:

  • Spawning a background job to run the process asynchronously. Easy because you don't have to recode much, but highly suspicous.
  • Examining why it seems necessary to do so much work on what ought to be a single INSERT into a sales table, with perhaps a few extra rows with some details. Much the better solution, but often very hard to see without a second pair of eyes to help you out.

So now we can move on to pure CRUD operations.

Let The Arguments Begin: Outbound CRUD

Outbound CRUD is any application code that grabs data from the database and passes it up to the Presentation layer.

A fully normalized database will, in appropriate cases, require business logic of the calculations variety, otherwise the display is not complete and meaningful to the user. There is really no getting around it in those cases.

However, a database Denormalized With Calculated Values requires no business logic for outbound CRUD, it only has to pick up what is asked for and pass it up. This is the route I prefer myself.

Deciding whether or not to include denormalized calculated values has heavy implications for the architecture of your system, but before we see why, we have to look at inbound CRUD.

Inbound CRUD

Inbound CRUD, in terms of business logic, is the mirror image of outbound. If your database is fully normalized, inbound CRUD should be free of business logic, since it is simply taking requests and pushing them to the database. However, if you are denormalizing by adding derived values, then it has to be done on the way in, so inbound CRUD code must contain business logic code of the calculations variety.

Now let us examine how the normalization question affects system architecture and application code.

Broken Symmetry

As stated above, denormalizing by including derived values forces calculated business logic on the inbound path, but frees your outbound path to be the "fast lane". The opposite decision, not storing calculated values, allows the inbound path to be the "fast lane" and forces the calculations into the outbound path.

The important conclusion is: if you have business logic of the calculation variety in both lanes then you may have some inconsistent practices, and there may be some gain involved in sorting those out.

But the two paths are not perfectly symmetric. Even a fully normalized database will often, sooner or later, commit those calculated values to columns. This usually happens when some definition of finality is met. Therefore, since the inbound path is more likely to contain calculations in any case, the two options are not really balanced. This is one reason why I prefer to store the calculated values and get them right on the way in.

One Final Option

When people ask me if I prefer to put business logic in the server, it is hard to answer without a lot of information about context. But when calculations are involved the answer is yes.

The reason is that calculations are incredibly easy to fit into patterns. The patterns themselves (almost) all follow foreign keys, since the foreign key is the only way to correctly relate data between tables. So you have the "FETCH" pattern, where a price is fetched from the items table to the cart, the "EXTEND" pattern, where qty * price = extended_Price, and various "AGGREGATE" patterns, where totals are summed up to the invoice. There are others, but it is surprising how many calculations fall into these patterns.

Because these patterns are so easy to identify, it is actually conceivable to code triggers by hand to do them, but being an incurable toolmaker, I prefer to have a code generator put them together out of a data dictionary. More on that around the first of the year.

Updates

Update 1: I realize I never made it quite clear that this is part 1, as the discussion so far seems reasonable but is hardly rigorous (yet). Part 2 will be on the way after I've fattened up for the holidays.

Update 2: It is well worth following the link Mr. Koppelaars has put in the comments: http://thehelsinkideclaration.blogspot.com/2009/03/window-on-data-applications.html

84 comments:

JulesLt said...

Validation is always an interesting one.

Anything more complex that simple data type checking is business logic - and that ranges from things like min & max allowed values, to more complex validations where the allowed values for B are dependent on the value of A.

We can implement these as constraints, ensuring the integrity of the database and protecting against rogue applications (and direct SQL).

We can implement them in our business objects - which is the proper way to do it. Constraints are therefore seen as wrong/evil as they implement business logic in the persistence layer. The application ensures the integrity of the data, and of course there will never ever be a second application / rewrite into a new language.

And then there is validation in the presentation layer itself. Again, this is the 'wrong' place to put business logic, but from a user perspective we all know how annoying it is to use a web application that only validates a form when you press submit. We like it when drop-lists are restricted based on previous input.

I'm not really sure what the answer is - obviously having the rules in the presentation layer ONLY is wrong, having the rules in the database only is too late - users do not want to see 'foreign key integrity constraint error on table PEOPLE'.

The business object only approach only seems to work when the presentation layer and business objects exist on the same tier - i.e. desktop applications. With client-server and the web request-response we end up needing some level of local/presentation layer code.

CASE tools and code generation were supposed to be the solution, but I think people were put off by finding themselves tied into dead products.

Toon Koppelaars said...

Nice post: it has been my interest too to find a clear definition of "business logic". Everybody uses the word, nobody ever provides a clear definition.
In my Helsinki-declaration I offer a definition, that's not too far away from what you are trying to achieve here. You can find it here:

http://thehelsinkideclaration.blogspot.com/2009/03/window-on-data-applications.html

I actually split the term "business logic" into "data logic" and "the rest" (also excluding all "UI-logic").

KenDowns said...

Toon:

I had actually just downloaded your document on Database-centric J2EE development, and am planning to cite it in early January in a post discussing the Fat-thin-fat model, which i have used exclusively since moving to web development.

I will read the Helsinki declaration and see if I can make a more detailed comment.

KenDowns said...

JulesLT:

"....is business logic - and that ranges from things like min & max allowed values..." Agreed. I deliberately glossed over these details for brevity, I'm glad you fleshed that out.

"...and of course there will never ever be a second application / rewrite into a new language." LOL.

Overall, it seems that all tiers at very least need to know about the business logic, especially the foundation schema with types and constraints. I think the best solution, using DRY, is to have a single authoritative data dictionary that can be used for many tasks, beginning with the database upgrade itself, but continuing through to publishing itself in various forms that can be used by other tiers.

Anonymous said...

I like this little non sequitur:

"...If this is true, that the term is non-technical, or if you like,
non-rigorous, then most of us spend the better part of our
efforts working on something that does not even have a
definition...."

Anonymous said...

"Inbound CRUD, in terms of business logic, is the mirror image of outbound. If your database is fully normalized, inbound CRUD should be free of business logic, since it is simply taking requests and pushing them to the database."

This seems either highly naive, or using too specific a definition of CRUD as to be useless.

Let's say I'm creating a user. Just an insert right? Well yes, but of many more values than I am supplying in the form. We need to store date at which the user was created, who created the user, their session id, perhaps a marketing affiliate or other source identification, and so on. Those values come from code that I would certainly call "business logic."

KenDowns said...

nyetter: Your point is well taken in cases where such items need to be added. However, I would still say that those items should be trivial to add, the date is nothing, the user is in context somewhere (like the session), and so the "fast lane" concept holds.

If by "affiliate information" you mean something fetched from another table, it is no longer "highly normalized" so the claim of inbound CRUD being simple no longer applies.

I've just about finished a new post, which I'm expecting to have finished for Jan 3rd, that goes the next step from a working definition to a rigorous definition. Not to give too much away, but in that system your example data would be "Second Order Business Logic".

Then if I ever get to it in copious free time, I believe the rigorous definition can be resolved to a formal definition.

Anonymous said...

Let me add my thanks for this discussion, Ken.

I have spent a long time considering "inbound crud", which I characterize as transaction logic - logic that must be executed as transactions are saved, for database integrity.

I suggest this consists of:
* multi-attribute/table constraints
(eg, balance < creditLimit)
* multi-attribute/table derivations
(eg, balance = sum (unpaid orders)
* actions
(eg, send mail, start process, auditing)

Accepting a Service Layer as an anti-pattern, I believe a good approach is a Rich Active Declarative Data Model.

By this, I mean utilize ORM events to encapsulate declarative multi-table transaction logic into ORM Domain Objects. The small examples above suggest the approach, which includes chaining and automated dependency management.

This approach can (really) replace 100 lines of code with a single rule, and can plug into existing architectures/frameworks since ORM APIs are preserved.

Perhaps hard to believe, but easy to check out - examples provided.

Anonymous said...

*controversy

Digitalbit said...

This is a good article & good site.Thank you for sharing this article. It is help us following categorize:
healthcare, e commerce, programming, multi platform,inventory management, cloud-based solutions, it consulting, retail, manufacturing, CRM, technology means, digital supply chain management, Delivering high-quality service for your business applications,
Solutions for all Industries,
Getting your applications talking is the key to better business processes,
Rapid web services solutions for real business problems,
Web-based Corporate Document Management System,
Outsourcing Solution,
Financial and Operations Business Intelligence Solution,

Our address:
2002 Timberloch Place, Suite 200
The Woodlands, TX 77380
281-364-1799

prologic-corp

prabha said...

Thanks for sharing the informative concept. Your data visualization contents are really good. You will explain the concept is a very clear and detailed explanation...
Informatica Online Training | Informatica Online Certification | Learn Informatica Course

Unknown said...

paito china
data sydney
datahk
syair sydney
syairsgp
datasgp
paito warna
http://warungsgp.com/
live hk 6d
live sydney

Aditi Sharma said...

Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this interesting and knowledgeable article. We are top CRM Software | CRM Software Mumbai | CRM Software Provider | CRM Software Pune | Field Management Software | CRM Software India

dewatampan said...

live draw hk banyak terdapat perbedaan dari situs2 penyedia live hk ini. Sedikit saran apabila anda setiap harinya mengikuti live draw hk kami pastikan selalu menggunakan situs live hk yang kami rekomendasikan saja. Termasuk juga untuk live draw sgp ataupun live sgp alternatif ini.

Kenneth Leitner said...

That's good content. I 've read lots of great news here five nights at freddy’s

yugaganteng said...

paito warna terlengkap
paito warna china
paito warna cambodia
paito warna singapore
live draw hk

anonymus said...

https://togelhoky1.blogspot.com/
https://togelresmi8.blogspot.com/
https://togelsgphk8.blogspot.com/
https://situstogelkita.blogspot.com/
https://togelonlinejudi.blogspot.com/
https://togel2020wap.blogspot.com/

anonymus said...

https://berbagitipshidupsehat1.blogspot.com/
https://tutorialdietsehat2.blogspot.com/
https://Healthydiet34.blogspot.com/
https://agentogelonlineterpercaya99.blogspot.com/
https://kingdomtoto88.blogspot.com/
https://royaltoto888.blogspot.com/
https://kinghorsetoto88.blogspot.com/
https://muliatoto888.blogspot.com/
https://98toto88.blogspot.com

Rashika said...

Wow!! Really a nice Article about Informatica. Thank you so much for your efforts. Definitely, it will be helpful for others. I would like to follow your blog. Share more like this. Thanks Again.

Java training in chennai | Java training in annanagar | Java training in omr | Java training in porur | Java training in tambaram | Java training in velachery

The Marketer said...

I enjoyed your blog Thanks for sharing such an informative post. We are also providing the best services click on below links to visit our website.

digital marketing company in nagercoil
digital marketing services in nagercoil
digital marketing agency in nagercoil
best marketing services in nagercoil
SEO company in nagercoil
SEO services in nagercoil
social media marketing in nagercoil
social media company in nagercoil
PPC services in nagercoil
digital marketing company in velachery
digital marketing company in velachery
digital marketing services in velachery
digital marketing agency in velachery
SEO company in velachery
SEO services in velachery
social media marketing in velachery
social media company in velachery
PPC services in velachery
online advertisement services in velachery
online advertisement services in nagercoil

web design company in nagercoil
web development company in nagercoil
website design company in nagercoil
website development company in nagercoil
web designing company in nagercoil
website designing company in nagercoil
best web design company in nagercoil
web design company in velachery
web development company in velachery
website design company in velachery
website development company in velachery
web designing company in velachery
website designing company in velachery
best web design company in velachery

Thanks for Sharing - ( Groarz branding solutions )

Sages Marketing said...

Very interesting blog. Many blogs I see these days do not really provide anything that attracts others, but believe me the way you interact is literally awesome.You can also check my articles as well.

Security Guard License
Ontario Security License
Security License Ontario
Security License

Thank you..

COCOTECH said...

Decent article, thankful for more information Activated carbon manufacturers in tamilnadu The information you gave about has been valuable while analyzing the subject.Activated carbon manufacturing companies in India

Scott Stayris said...

I am glad that you shared this helpful information. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.
Quickbooks online file

Social Media Marketing Agency said...

Extraordinary Blog...The information you shared is amazingly, It is all around wrote and simple to undertand and social media marketing agency in chennai you have good thoughts to share something like this a debt of gratitude is in order for share this information.

Anna Marinata said...

You write very good! Have you thought about instagram blog? I think you can lead it and I know where to get insta followers, from this site https://soclikes.com/

Golden Triangle Tour Package said...

Thanks for sharing this great article. It made me understand few things about this concept which I never knew before. Keep posting such great articles Golden Triangle Tour Package

Maze Tech Inc said...

SEO for Dental
SEO for Pharma
SEO for Healthcare
SEO Company in Chennai
Digital Marketing Training in Chennai
SEO Consultant Chennai
Web Designing in Chennai

Top 10 Makeup Artists in Kolkata said...

Thank you for your outstanding article. I like your content. They are very useful article. Thanks for sharing us. Top 10 Makeup Artists in Kolkata

emailtaai said...

Software development company in Noida team has to perform in accord with the client's engineering team for ideal results. Techsaga Corporations address this facet of the software development process most aggressively with our streamlined and well-planned resources.

aditya said...

Good post thanks for share information.

AppValley VIP APK
Cami Elliott
lola Iolani Momoa
rolling paper alternatives
Mp3boo

wholesale germany jewerly said...

In this essay we will pursue a method of finding operations that we can define as business logic with a minimum of controversey, and identify those that can likely be excluded with a minimum of controversey. This may leave a bit of gray area that can be taken up in a later post. bar necklace usa , locket necklace wholesale france

القمر السعودى said...

شركة مكافحة حشرات بالدمام

Jhonny said...

Thank you for your post, I look for such article along time. myself very happy to read it because it can give me more insight, thanks.. Visit my blog..thankyou

Joker88 Slot
Sbowin
Sbobet88
Bola338

Agus Salim said...

I just loved your article on the beginners guide to starting a blog.If somebody take this blog article seriously in their life, he/she can earn his living by doing blogging.

Sbobet
Judi Online 88
Hokibet77
Naga slot

Jamroni Sumardi said...

It’s really a great and helpful piece of information. I’m satisfied that you simply shared this useful info with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.

Joker88 Asia
Qqslot88
Fafa slot
Fafaslot

ANDI said...

This list is so inspiring! and this is very good blog post website i never thought that this post is very much informatic and usefull to us.

Mpo Slot
Nowgoal Vip
Fafaslot
Playsbo

randi said...

Thanks for the sharing this blog with us. I like it very much. I have blog , can you visit my blog if you want to see my website, thankyou

Sbobet88 Mobile
Poker Play
Idn Poker
Idn 88

Juminto99 said...

Your File is Very Usefull File... Thanks For Uploading.... Please More File Uploading... Please Visit Our Website

Balak99
Bigslot777
Slot Deposit Pulsa
Joker88

Robby said...

Thanks For Sharing Your article It is very useful us and amazing blog for the users who want to learn

Joker88 Slot
Slot Pulsa
Slot777
Megawin77

Sulaiman Sihombing said...

I got this web blog from my buddy who told me concerning this web blog and at the moment this time I am browsing this web page and reading very informative articles here.

Sbobet Slot
Sbobet Slot
Slot Joker123
Daftar Slot Pulsa

Jesica Salim said...

Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I am impressed! Extremely useful information specifically the last part �� I care for such information a lot. I was seeking this certain info for a very long time. Thank you and good luck.

Hokibet77

asdas said...

Thank you for your post, myself very happy to read it because it can give me more insight, thanks.. Visit my blog..thankyou

Slot77 Online
Raja Slot88

Arwan Singgih said...

Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I really appreciate your efforts and I will be
waiting for your next post thank you once again.

Big Slot77
Fa Fa Slot
Live22 Slot
Poker77
Domino77

Arista Keano said...

I was more than happy to find this site. I need
to to thank you for ones time just for this fantastic read!!
I definitely really liked every little bit of it and I have you saved as a favorite to look at new things on your site. Thankyou for sharing.

Bandar888
88Sbobet
Mpo88
Mpo Slot
Mpo303

Saveri Abel said...

This paragraph is genuinely a nice one it helps new net users, who are wishing
in favor of blogging. Thankyou for sharing.

Mpo338
Megajoker88
Sbobetasia888
Mpobola
Hoki99

Reiki Savian said...

Every weekend i used to pay a visit this web page, because i want enjoyment, since
this this site conations actually fastidious funny
information too. Thankyou for sharing.

Mpo66
Mpo33
Mpo10
Mpo18
Mpo81

Falefi Jaasir said...

Asking questions are genuinely good thing if you are not understanding
anything completely, except this post gives nice understanding yet. Thankyou for sharing.

Mpo5000
Mpo005
Mpo222 Slot
Joker88
Mpo168

Kenzo Julian said...

Heya i'm for the first time here. I found this board
and I find It truly useful & it helped me out a lot.
I hope to give something back and help others like you helped
Thankyou for sharing.

Mpo12 Slot
Mpo77 Slot
Mpo7 Slot
Mpo99
Raja88 Slot

Danial Arsalan said...

Good article! We will be linking to this particularly great content on our website.
Keep up the great writing.
Thankyou for sharing.

Login Sbowin
Dingdong Buah
Login Dewa Slot
Daftar Slot Online
Slot777 Asia

Kin Dhananjaya said...

Everything is very open with a precise explanation of the challenges.
It was truly informative. Your website is extremely helpful.
Thanks for sharing!

Hoki Slot Mobile
Login Sbobet Mobile
Bet88 Casino
Daftar Bet88
Slot Habanero Login

Muhammad Kevlar said...

Incredible! This blog looks just like my old one! It's on a totally different subject but it has pretty much the same layout and design. Great choice of colors! Thankyou for sharing.

Joker777
Bola888
Bola388
Slot77 Login
Bola777

Ruri Narendra said...

I really like your blog.. very nice colors & theme.
Did you create this website yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you?
Plz reply as I'm looking to construct my own blog and would like to
know where u got this from. thank you

Bola188 Link
Bola365 Login
Joker88 Download
Login Habanero Slot
Scatter Slot

Ardian Adhlino said...

I got this web blog from my buddy who told me concerning this web blog and at the moment this time I am browsing this web page and reading very informative articles here. Thankyou for sharing.

1001slot
Megajoker88 Slot
Joker88 Login
Slot777
Mpo5 Slot

AdhitamaElvan said...

Oh my goodness! Impressive article dude! Thank you, However I am going through difficulties with your RSS. I don’t know the reason why I am unable to join it. Is there anybody else having the same RSS problems?
Anyone that knows the solution will you kindly respond? Thanks!!

Mpo Indo36
Joker88 Gaming
Joker88 Apk Download
Raja Slot88 Link Alternatif
Joker88 Login

periyannan said...

Very nice blog and articles.
Internship providing companies in chennai | Where to do internship | internship opportunities in Chennai | internship offer letter | What internship should i do | How internship works | how many internships should i do ? | internship and inplant training difference | internship guidelines for students | why internship is necessary

Jumanto said...

"Oh my goodness! Impressive article dude! Thank you, However I am going through difficulties with your RSS. I don’t know the reason why I am unable to join it. Is there anybody else having the same RSS problems?
Anyone that knows the solution will you kindly respond? Thanks!!"

Slot Mania
Slot168
Slot303

WSLOT99 said...

WSLOT99 merupakan Situs Slot Online Terpercaya dan Resmi di Indonesia yang menyediakan berbagai permainan game Judi Online Terbaik.
Promo yang berlaku di WSLOT99 :
✅ BONUS NEW MEMBER 50%
✅ BONUS DEPOSIT HARIAN 5%
✅ BONUS ROLLINGAN 0.5%
✅ BONUS CASHBACK 5%
✅ BONUS REFFERAL UP TO 1%
Terima Deposit Via E-Wallet dan Pulsa Telkomsel XL !#!
agen slot online terpercaya
slot deposit dana
slot gacor
slot deposit pulsa
situs slot online

Aksa Delvin said...

It’s in reality a nice and useful piece of info. I’m satisfied that you shared this useful information with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.

Jokergaming123
Slot007
Joker88 Slot
Daftar Jokergaming123
Slotwin777

Neandro Sabian said...

Thank you a bunch for sharing this with all people you really recognize what you are talking approximately! Bookmarked. Kindly also seek advice from my web site =). We may have a link alternate arrangement among us!

Slot Fa Fa Fa
Scater Slot
Vegas Slot 777
88fortune Login
Scatter Fafa

Adinata Aileen said...

Thanks for every other fantastic post. Where else may just anybody get that kind of info in such a perfect approach of writing? I’ve a presentation next week, and I’m at the look for such info.

Fafaslot88
Mpo Slot Online
Lucky777 Slot
Mpo222
Slot mania88

Ansell Arian said...

Wonderful beat ! I wish to apprentice while you amend your web site, how could i subscribe for a blog web site? The account helped me a acceptable deal. I had been a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast provided bright clear idea

88fortunes Slot
Fafafa Uang Asli
Megawin88
Mega77 Slot
Spbobet1

Eros Bratadikara said...

Great web site. A lot of useful information here. I am sending it to some friends ans additionally sharing in delicious. And naturally, thank you on your sweat!

Sbobet388
Idn Slot 168 Pulsa
777lucky Login
Sbobet Slot
Daftar Lucky Slot

Abimanyu Damar said...

I was more than happy to seek out this internet-site.I wished to thanks in your time for this wonderful learn!! I definitely having fun with every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to take a look at new stuff you blog post.

Slot1881
Lucky Slot77
Dragon 4d Slot
Slot Win777
Agensbobet888

Alvaro Argi said...

You made some clear points there. I looked on the internet for the topic and found most guys will go along with with your site.

Qq988
Jagoslot88 Login Mobile
Daftar Slotwin88
Daftar Slotwin777
Mas888 Slot Login

Matthew Davis said...

I am no longer positive where you’re getting your information, however great topic. I must spend some time studying more or understanding more. Thank you for magnificent info I used to be in search of this info for my mission.

Macauslot 303
Link Alternatif Sbobet
Lucky 777 Slot
Hoki Asia
Slot Royal88

Lily Lazareva said...

Hey very cool site!! Man .. Excellent .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your web site and take the feeds also…I am happy to find a lot of useful information here in the post, we need develop more techniques in this regard, thanks for sharing.

Joker88 Slot
Lapakjoker 777
Jpjoker123 Link Alternatif
Mitosjoker Download
Superwin77 Link Alternatif

Olesya Uvarova said...

Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read anything like this before. So nice to seek out somebody with some authentic thoughts on this subject. realy thank you for starting this up. this website is one thing that is needed on the internet, somebody with a little originality. useful job for bringing one thing new to the internet!

Slot88 Online Deposit Pulsa
Imb88 Mobile
Daftar Raja Slot88
Raja Slot 888
Api Dewa Slot Game

tresa fowler said...

I’m still learning from you, but I’m trying to reach my goals. I absolutely liked reading all that is posted on your website. Keep the articles coming. I liked it!

Api Dewa Slot Online
Dewa Slot 88 Login
Raja Slot 999
Daftar Master888 Slot
Slot59

Minnie Guizar said...

I’m typically to running a blog and i really admire your content. The article has really peaks my interest. I’m going to bookmark your site and preserve checking for brand spanking new information.

Winbet88 Link Alternatif
Daftar Agen777 Online
Daftar Ratuslot99 Mobile
Joker777
Ozzo Gaming Login

periyannan said...

This article is very much helpful and i hope this will be an useful information for the needed one. Keep on updating these kinds of informative things...

python internship | web development internship |internship for mechanical engineering students|mechanical engineering internships|java training in chennai |internship for 1st year engineering students |online internships for cse students|online internship for engineering students |internship for ece students|data science internships |

Royalcasino254 said...

Royalcasino254

Sylvia Quill said...

You're so cool! I dont suppose Ive learn something like this before. So nice to find anyone with some authentic thoughts on this subject. Really thanks for starting this up. this web site is something that’s needed on the net, someone with a little bit originality. Helpful job for bringing something new to the internet!

Royal 88 Slot
Slotku88
Slot303
396slot
Slot396

Richard Butler said...

I haven’t checked in here for some time since I thought it was getting boring, but the last few posts are good quality so I guess I will add you back to my daily bloglist. You deserve it my friend

Dewa4d Slot
Mpo1000
Slot98
Hoki138 Slot
Hoki888

Randy Stickler said...

Nice information, valuable and excellent design, as share good stuff with good ideas and concepts, Got lots of great information and inspiration, both of which I need, thanks to offer such a helpful information here.

Hokislot188
Slothoki88
Hoki188
Slot123
Gacor777

Gwendolyn Vu said...

An interesting discussion might be priced at comment. I do think that you need to write read more about this topic, it might be described as a taboo subject but typically consumers are not enough to communicate on such topics. To another location. Cheers

Zeus Slot
Slot1388
Asia 999 Casino
Bola138
Rajaslot77

Charlotte Baylis said...

For a long time, I & my friend were searching for informative blogs, but now I am in the right place guys, you have made a room in my heart.

Casinoslot88
Ligaslot
Mpoplay99
Slot Deposit Dana
Slot Deposit Ovo

Leonard Holmes said...

Quality articles or reviews is the key to interest the visitors to
pay a visit the web page, that's what this site is providing.

Qqarena88
Lux888
Lux777
Lux77
Wawasan Slot
Big888 Slot

Milapra said...

I am very excited because I can get this very good information, This is one of the really very helpful information, I hope you keep updating other up-to-date information that may be useful to me as well as to many others.

Slot88 Asia
Link Alternatif Daftar Slot77
777 Slot Casino
Rgo Slot365

Robby Patria said...

This site is very helpful and gives me a lot of inspiration, so I want to say thank you.. I hope this site continues to grow.

Daftar Bet88 Togel Online
Daftar Mpo88 Deposit Pulsa
Daftar Mpo123
Mpo99 Deposit Pulsa

Bang Jono said...

Thanks for sharing this excellent post, I am going to share it as an external reference link in a post I am writing on Guest Posting.

Daftar Mpo Slot Terbaru
Daftar Mpo Slot
Daftar Mpo757
Daftar Mpo222 Online

Aulia Pratama said...

I just loved your article on the beginners guide to starting a blog.If somebody take this blog article seriously in their life, he/she can earn his living by doing blogging.

Daftar Slot777
Daftar Joker Gaming
Daftar Slot303 Mobile
Slot88 Deposit Pulsa

PutriWu said...

You know your projects stand out of the herd. There is something special about them. It seems to me all of them are really brilliant!

Sbobet88 Online
Sbobet Wap
Slot88
Daftar Bet88

Sahputra said...

I like this topic.This site has lots of advantage.I found many interesting things from this site. It helps me in many ways.Thanks for posting this again.

Mpo005
Mpo Slot
Daftar Mpoplay
Daftar Mpo81 Mobile

Juandra said...

Great work !! Looking forward to more of such good work, Thanks for sharing this helpful information with us.

Slot Hoki VIP
Daftar Mpo33 Mobile